Our decision to publish the chain of emails between our campaign and Norfolk & Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust (NSFT) finally forced a response from Michael Scott, the £175,000 per year Chief Executive of NSFT, on 30th April 2015. We submitted our original FOI request in December 2014. NSFT is supposed to respond in 20 days.
Michael Scott acknowledges that NSFT does have the report we seek, “Understanding the Impact of Trust Service Strategy on staff working in the Central Adult Service Line”. We believe the report, also known as The Alexander Report, details the catastrophic impact of the radical redesign on mental health services. However, Scott claims that releasing the report:
“would or would be likely to inhibit:
i. the free and frank provision of advice, or
ii. the free and frank provision exchange [sic] of views for the purpose of deliberation”
Scott continues:
“Having considered the public interest, the Trust has reached the conclusion that the public interest balance lies in favour of maintaining the exemption and withholding the information.”
Michael Scott appears to believe that the self-serving protection of the personal reputations and lucrative jobs of the NSFT Board of Directors and the clinical and operational management involved in the imposition of the disastrous radical redesign is more important than staff well-being, safeguarding public money, transparency and public accountability which are essential components of the delivery of safe and high quality mental health services.
Here is what Robert Francis QC had to say about Mid Staffs:
“This is a story of appalling and unnecessary suffering of hundreds of people.
“They were failed by a system which ignored the warning signs and put corporate self-interest and cost control ahead of patients and their safety.”
He said the public’s trust in the NHS had been “betrayed” and a change of culture was needed to “make sure that patients come first”.
Michael Scott expects us to be content with NSFT’s official history of the radical redesign, which can be summarized as “Some people, some of whom have left, may have made some unspecified mistakes which have been exaggerated.”
Frankly, this will not do.
You can read Michael Scott’s letter in full here.
Below is our response which was submitted today.
We will not rest until the truth is out.
By email to:
Michael Scott, Chief Executive
Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust, Trust Management, 1st Floor Admin Block, Hellesdon Hospital, Drayton High Road, Hellesdon NR6 5BE
cc.
[redacted], FOI Administrator
Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust, Compliance Team, Kestral House, Hellesdon Hospital, Drayton High Road, NR6 5BE
13th May 2015
Dear Mr. Scott,
We acknowledge receipt on 30th April 2015 of your undated letter responding to the Campaign’s email request of 16/12/14 and 25/02/15 for sight of a document we now know is called “Understanding the Impact of Trust Service Strategy on staff working in the Central Adult Service Line“ (“the Report”).
We do not accept your conclusion that disclosure would inhibit the provision of advice nor the frank exchange of views for the purpose of deliberation. We understood that the purpose of the Report was to identify and thereby understand what was going on in terms of the impact on staff and on the delivery of services. We are not aware that advice is being sought nor provided. If that is so, please accept a further FOI request to give details from whom advice is being sought and the time frames for receiving it. Nor were we aware that there is any process of deliberation currently being carried out pursuant to the Report. If that is so, please accept a further FOI request for details, when it began and when it ended or is expected to end.
We firmly believe that it is in the public interest to disseminate the impact of the Trust Service Strategy. This will inform future decision making around the provision of services, patient safety and staff engagement. We understand that the staff who participated in the survey did so anonymously and that there is no way to trace the responses to individuals. In those circumstances the disclosure of the Report is not likely to inhibit those taking part in future reviews. Participants are more likely to be discouraged from further participation if they feel that reports are buried and no action taken upon them.
However if it the position that the participants were informed that the information they provided would not be disseminated nor published (even as anonymized data) please under FOI provide (i) the document which was given to the participants stating this and (ii) how long you intend to treat this information as confidential.
By this letter the Campaign requests an internal review which we expect to be completed within 20 working days of today’s date. This deadline is very important in view of your failure to deal with our original request of 16 December 2014 (which apparently you did not receive) and that the start date was set back to 25th February 2015 (the date of our chasing email). Even taking the later of these dates, your reply received on 30th April exceeded the deadline by 26 working days. As you have sought to rely section 36, you should have informed the requester/Campaign within 20 days of 25th February that section 36 is engaged and that the Trust were intending to extend the time limit. This was not done and according to your record of the qualified person’s opinion which accompanied your response, the date on which the opinion was sought was 27th March. A further month then elapsed before this was completed and then communicated to us.
In these circumstances and in order to progress this matter in a timely manner (bearing in mind the importance of the Report on patient safety) we will treat a failure to provide us with the outcome of the internal review within 20 working days of receipt of this letter/email i.e. on or before the 11th June 2015 as a failure to hold an internal review and we will draw that to the attention of the Information Commissioner.
Perhaps if and when this report is published the clinical leads and managers who ignored us all when we said their vicious cuts were disastrous will be held to account particularly Dr Horne who pushed through the cuts based on inaccurate data and then disappeared into Youth/EI/80SS never to be seen at Gateway or Peddars again. Those responsible cannot hold positions of authority.
great article
Excellent write-up
reputable indian online pharmacy https://indiaph24.store/# cheapest online pharmacy india
top 10 pharmacies in india
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexico pharmacy – medicine in mexico pharmacies
mexico drug stores pharmacies: Mexican Pharmacy Online – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
mexican pharmacy: Mexican Pharmacy Online – mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://indiaph24.store/# buy medicines online in india
india pharmacy mail order Cheapest online pharmacy indian pharmacy paypal
http://indiaph24.store/# indian pharmacy paypal
http://indiaph24.store/# reputable indian online pharmacy
http://ciprofloxacin.tech/# buy cipro online
buying generic propecia: buying generic propecia without dr prescription – get generic propecia without insurance
lisinopril cheap brand lisinopril 20mg 25mg zestril 20 mg price canadian pharmacy
http://finasteride.store/# buy cheap propecia without rx
buy cytotec pills: order cytotec online – cytotec online
buy cipro online ciprofloxacin generic price ?»?cipro generic
lisinopril 100 mg lisinopril sale lisinopril 10 mg order online
https://cytotec.club/# purchase cytotec
http://finasteride.store/# cost of generic propecia price
buy cytotec over the counter: Misoprostol 200 mg buy online – cytotec pills online
http://lisinopril.network/# prinivil generic
how does tamoxifen work: tamoxifen cancer – tamoxifen endometrium
cheap propecia price order cheap propecia price cost of propecia without a prescription
http://ciprofloxacin.tech/# buy ciprofloxacin
https://finasteride.store/# generic propecia
ciprofloxacin generic price: ciprofloxacin generic price – cipro online no prescription in the usa
tamoxifen cyp2d6 where to get nolvadex aromatase inhibitor tamoxifen
https://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen and osteoporosis
raloxifene vs tamoxifen: tamoxifen chemo – how to get nolvadex
lisinopril 40 mg price in india zestril medicine lisinopril 40 mg mexico
http://cytotec.club/# buy cytotec pills online cheap
cost of propecia for sale get generic propecia online buying propecia tablets
ciprofloxacin generic price: cipro online no prescription in the usa – ciprofloxacin generic price
https://finasteride.store/# order propecia without prescription
http://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen bone density
buy generic propecia without a prescription get propecia without rx buying generic propecia no prescription
ciprofloxacin generic price: buy cipro online – cipro 500mg best prices
how to buy lisinopril online where to buy lisinopril 2.5 mg buy generic lisinopril
http://nolvadex.life/# tamoxifen blood clots
tamoxifen and grapefruit: does tamoxifen cause menopause – tamoxifen breast cancer prevention
https://cytotec.club/# cytotec online
price of lisinopril 5mg lisinopril 40 mg tablets 20 mg lisinopril tablets
http://lisinopril.network/# 30mg lisinopril
get generic propecia tablets: cost of generic propecia online – cost cheap propecia without a prescription
cost cheap propecia without prescription cost cheap propecia price cost of propecia without prescription
propecia generic: buy propecia no prescription – get propecia without dr prescription
lisinopril 20 mg price online drug lisinopril buy lisinopril no prescription
https://viagras.online/# Buy Viagra online cheap
Generic Cialis price: Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription – Buy Tadalafil 5mg
https://cialist.pro/# Cheap Cialis
Purchase Cenforce Online order cenforce order cenforce
https://viagras.online/# Viagra online price
http://viagras.online/# viagra without prescription
Buy Cialis online Cialis 20mg price in USA buy cialis pill
Cheap generic Viagra online: viagras.online – Viagra without a doctor prescription Canada
http://kamagra.win/# buy kamagra online usa
cenforce.pro cheapest cenforce Purchase Cenforce Online
https://cenforce.pro/# Cenforce 150 mg online
sildenafil oral jelly 100mg kamagra kamagra pills Kamagra 100mg price
http://cenforce.pro/# cenforce for sale
http://viagras.online/# Generic Viagra for sale
https://pharmnoprescription.icu/# no prescription medication
us pharmacy no prescription pharm world store rx pharmacy no prescription
pet meds without vet prescription canada: canadian drugs pharmacy – safe canadian pharmacy
https://pharmmexico.online/# mexico pharmacy
online pharmacy that does not require a prescription canadian pharmacy no prescription buy medications online without prescription
https://pharmnoprescription.icu/# online drugs without prescription
uk pharmacy no prescription pharm world store cheapest pharmacy to get prescriptions filled
purple pharmacy mexico price list: mexican pharmaceuticals online – mexico pharmacy
cheapest pharmacy canada: onlinecanadianpharmacy 24 – canadian pharmacy online store
https://pharmmexico.online/# mexican mail order pharmacies
best rated canadian pharmacy legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy 77 canadian pharmacy
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
http://pharmmexico.online/# mexican drugstore online
legal canadian pharmacy online: global pharmacy canada – online pharmacy canada
http://pharmmexico.online/# mexican rx online
mexico online pharmacy prescription drugs ordering prescription drugs from canada medications online without prescriptions
neurontin 300 mg cap: neurontin 800 – neurontin tablets no script
buy prednisone 10 mg prednisone without prescription prednisone 60 mg price
zithromax 500 mg lowest price pharmacy online: average cost of generic zithromax – where can i purchase zithromax online
neurontin 100mg cost neurontin 100mg capsule price gabapentin buy
can you buy amoxicillin over the counter: amoxicillin 500 coupon – amoxicillin 500 mg online
prednisone online india: prednisone buying – can i order prednisone
http://doxycyclinea.online/# doxycycline mono